If you hire 1099 help or plan to, having a system for independent contractor payroll in place before you start paying contractors can help prevent issues.
What you’ll learn
What you’ll learn
Key takeaways
- For the 2026 tax year, collect W-9s electronically before your first payment, and use software to track the new $2,000 threshold.
- To maintain clear boundaries and prevent misclassification between W-2 employees and 1099 contractors, disable employee features like benefits and PTO tracking.
- Actively verify Taxpayer Identification Numbers (TIN) to avoid the mandatory 24% backup withholding tax if a contractor provides incorrect information.
- Eliminate manual entry to keep your 1099-NEC and 1099-MISC payments separated throughout the year, and sync payroll data directly to your accounting software.
Whether you are working with freelancers for the first time or looking for a refresher on how 1099s are paid, this guide covers common best practices to make paying contractors hassle-free.
Get that W-9
Before you write a check, obtain the contractor’s W-9. You’ll need this to make sure you have the correct information and that the person is legitimate. It will list their first name, last name, business structure, tax ID information, and the info you’ll need to pay them for the projects they work on. You hold onto this document and don’t need to share it with the IRS.
- Automate digital collection: Use a contractor self-service portal to securely collect and store W-9s, so you don’t have to manually request paperwork.
- Avoid email vulnerabilities: Asking a new freelancer to provide their Social Security number via email is a major security risk.
Why is this important?
Digital collection makes it much easier to securely onboard independent contractors at scale while keeping sensitive Taxpayer Identification Numbers out of vulnerable email inboxes.
“Getting this form before a contractor logs a single hour is your best defense against year-end compliance headaches. If a freelancer pushes back on providing their information, it’s a red flag and a signal that you should look for help elsewhere.”
— Noel Lorenzana, CPA and OnPay contributor
Set payment terms
The W-9 is a standard requirement when working with 1099 contractors. In addition, starting a project with a freelancer typically means agreeing on the work to be completed and the amount the individual will be paid.
- Focus on deliverables: Paying by the project rather than by the hour suggests you care more about the deliverable than about controlling the hours spent to get there.
- Define the compensation structure: Clearly state whether the individual will be paid by the hour or by the project.
Why is this important?
Defining how and when a freelancer gets paid establishes a professional relationship from the start and helps prevent confusion or potential invoice disputes.
Pick a payment method
Paying by check? Credit card? Are these folks sending you a link to pay through, or are you providing info over the phone by sharing a number? It seems straightforward but settle this issue at the beginning so you can pay people accurately and on time.
- Prioritize direct deposit: Mailing paper checks can be a slow, costly process — over 90% of people are paid via direct deposit.
- Accommodate flexible schedules: Contractors are often paid on irregular schedules. Having a system that supports weekly, monthly, or milestone-based direct deposits prevents administrative headaches.
Why is this important?
Setting up a reliable, fast payment method like direct deposit helps your business save money on administrative costs while ensuring your contractors are paid accurately and on time.
Keep classification clear
Uncle Sam takes worker classification seriously. Treating a freelancer like a traditional employee, such as setting their exact hours, micromanaging their workflow, or offering company-sponsored health insurance, often blurs legal boundaries and could trigger an audit.
- Maintain clear boundaries: Keep your rosters organized to prove you are maintaining clear legal boundaries between full-time employees and freelancers.
- Disable employee features: Use a misclassification safety net in your software for contract help to automatically turn off features like tax withholdings, benefits enrollment, and PTO tracking.
Why is this important?
Maintaining separation in your software helps reduce the risk of worker misclassification, which can trigger steep penalties and unwelcome (and avoidable) government audits.
Know the new threshold
There’s now a $2,000 threshold thanks to the One Big Beautiful Bill that passed in 2025. This means that if you pay contractors for work they complete in 2026, you only need to send them a 1099 if you pay them $2,000 or more during the year.
- Automate your tracking: Your payroll software should track total payments throughout the year, so you aren’t caught off guard when you cross the new $2,000 threshold.
- Avoid the double-reporting trap: Do not issue a 1099 if payments were made by credit card or through third-party platforms like PayPal or Stripe. They may already have their own reporting requirements.
Why is this important?
Automated tracking keeps you from being caught off guard by the new $2,000 reporting requirement, keeping you compliant without the headache of manual calculations.
1099-NEC and 1099-MISC
Make sure you have a filing plan to submit IRS forms. The annual deadline for getting these to contractors is January 31. For the 2026 tax year, you’ll have a small grace period since 1/31 falls on a weekend in 2027 (Sunday), so you have until Monday, February 1. Waiting until the last minute can cause stress for you and the person you hired!
- Provide lifetime account access: Look for software that gives contractors lifetime access to download their own 1099s so you spend less time responding to paperwork requests.
- Eliminate manual tracking: To save yourself from a major administrative burden when tax season arrives, ensure your system automatically generates Form 1099-NEC.
Why is this important?
Giving your contractors lifetime access to download their own tax forms eliminates administrative bottlenecks and ensures you meet strict end-of-year filing deadlines without a last-minute scramble.
“If you accidentally issue a 1099-MISC instead of a 1099-NEC, file a corrected 1099-NEC immediately to dodge IRS penalties. Just make sure to check the ‘Corrected’ box at the top of the new document, and ensure both the IRS and the contractor get the updated copy.”
— David Kindness, CPA and OnPay contrbutor
Actively verify TINs to prevent backup withholding
Once you get that W-9, don’t just file it away. Verifying the Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN) is a critical step to ensure the IRS has the correct information.
- Use IRS verification: Take advantage of the IRS TIN Matching program to confirm that the contractor’s name and TIN match government records.
- Execute mandatory withholding: If a contractor fails to provide a correct TIN, the IRS requires you to withhold a flat 24% tax from their payments (called backup withholding).
- Know the threshold: This backup withholding rule kicks in once their total annual pay crosses the new $2,000 threshold for the year.
Why is this important?
Catching a TIN mismatch early prevents you from having to enforce the mandatory 24% backup withholding tax once a contractor’s pay crosses the $2,000 threshold.
Keep 1099-NEC and 1099-MISC payments separate
It pays to stay organized throughout the year, so you aren’t scrambling in January.
- Isolate human services: Form 1099-NEC is specifically for non-employee compensation, such as the fees and commissions you pay to freelancers for their services.
- Isolate passive costs: Form 1099-MISC is reserved for non-service payments — including things like rent, awards, or legal settlements.
- Maintain records: To satisfy IRS audit standards, keep your tax records, invoices, and receipts for at least four years.
Why is this important?
Separating service-based compensation throughout the year saves you from organizational mishaps in January while satisfying IRS recordkeeping standards.
“It’s easy to fall into the double-reporting trap if you aren’t paying close attention to how your money moves. If you use a credit card or a third-party platform like Stripe or PayPal to pay a contractor, they usually handle the reporting for you. Issuing your own 1099 on top of that can create confusion for the IRS and the freelancer.”
— Marit Burmood, CPA, EA, and small business consultant
Integrate contractor payroll data with your accounting software
Manual data entry is a surefire way to introduce errors into your bookkeeping.
- Sync accounting engines: Connect your payroll processing tools directly to your accounting software to keep everything in one place.
- Eliminate manual entry: Using a payroll service that handles both W-2 employees and 1099 contractors means your data syncs automatically, saving you time during bank reconciliations.
- Streamline year-end reporting: With everything integrated, generating those year-end 1099s and tracking the $2,000 threshold becomes a seamless process.
Why is this important?
Syncing payroll processing and accounting tools eliminates human data entry errors and drastically reduces the time you spend on bank reconciliations.
Bottom line: Have a process for paying 1099s
Tapping contractors for help is a common way to access top talent without the payroll tax obligations of hiring full-time employees. However, relying on 1099 help comes with specific compliance rules and reporting obligations to manage. By setting up a reliable system before you start paying contractors, you can prevent administrative headaches from arising down the road. Following the best practices we have covered will go a long way to keep your business compliant, so you can focus on getting your team paid accurately and on time. If you need help along the way, our OnPay team is here to answer your questions.
Take a tour to see how easy payroll can be.
Jon Davis is the Sr. Content Marketing Manager at OnPay. He has over 15 years of experience writing for small and growing businesses. Jon lives and works in Atlanta.