Accurate payroll and employee classification are best practices for small and mid-sized businesses (SMBs) for a reason. In fact, over half of US states have established task forces to specifically combat misclassifying workers, according to the National Employment Law Project. That’s where a job audit comes in. A simple but effective tool for ensuring each role is properly defined, compensated, and compliant with current regulations.
What you’ll learn
What you’ll learn
Key takeaways about job audits
- SMBs can use job audits to define job roles, ensuring that they accurately classify employees and comply with local, state, and federal labor laws
- Job audits involve four key steps: information gathering, classification review, validation of pay scales and decision-making, and the establishment of ongoing practices
- These audits work to ensure fair compensation for employees, which helps boost job satisfaction and productivity
- Payroll software can automate the auditing process, reducing errors and integrating job audits into a broader HR strategy
It’s critical not only for staying compliant and avoiding costly penalties but also to ensure you are paying your employees fairly. This article will cover what job audits are, why they matter for SMBs, the steps you should take to conduct one, and how technology can help.
What is a job audit?
A job audit is a formal review of an employee’s role, responsibilities, and compensation. But here’s the twist: evaluating the individual’s performance does not enter the equation. It’s a systematic process that compares an employee’s job description with their everyday duties to determine if they’re correctly classified and fairly paid.
The takeaway? Mistakes in defining job roles, pay structures, or exempt vs. nonexempt employees can result in tax audits, fines, or even lawsuits. A well thought out auditing plan helps you to avoid such issues.
To ensure accurate worker classification and compliant payroll processes, conduct a job description audit and pay assessment for each employee. This not only protects you from costly fines and penalties but cultivates a culture of transparency and ethics.
How conducting a job audit protects your business and employees
Job audits can be mutually beneficial for small business owners and their employees. Everyone wins when workers are paid fairly and your business avoids legal and financial roadblocks.
Done correctly, routine job audits can:
- Reduce payroll errors
- Ensure fair compensation
- Maintain legal compliance
- Improve employee performance
- Boost organizational efficiency
Job audits can be even more important for SMBs than large companies. This is because smaller organizations typically don’t have a dedicated HR team to handle payroll and employee classifications. Therefore, job audits can act as a crucial safeguard against organizational and interpersonal fallouts, such as common payroll issues.
Key payroll risks addressed by job audits
When focusing on daily business operations, don’t miss the bigger picture. By reviewing job roles and compensation structures, you can preemptively identify and correct payroll errors before they escalate into legal or financial hardships.
Take a look at three major payroll risks that job audits help address.
Misclassification of employees
One of the most common payroll slipups that SMBs make is misclassifying employees as exempt or nonexempt, or as independent contractors rather than employees. A job description audit works to clarify actual job duties and verify that they align with legal definitions and requirements. This can help you avoid wage claims and IRS penalties down the road.
Incorrect pay rates and overtime errors
If job descriptions are unclear or outdated, you run the risk of paying your workers based on the wrong employee pay scale or inadvertently denying them proper overtime pay. Audits allow you to verify that you’re fairly paying your employees. This is based on job responsibilities and correctly assessing overtime eligibility, which reduces the risk of wage disputes.
Compliance penalties and financial exposure
Failing to comply with labor laws puts a business at risk for getting hit with costly audits, fines, and lawsuits. Job audits help you adhere to federal, state, and local regulations, including pay requirements under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). This protects your business from unforeseen liabilities and reputational damage.
Steps to conduct an effective job audit
How do you perform a job audit? When you approach it systematically, the process doesn’t have to be time-consuming or complex.
Here’s a step by step guide to conducting an effective job audit.
1. Gather accurate job descriptions
Develop an accurate job description for each employee:
- Review existing documentation: Collate and check current job descriptions, past audits, and payroll records
- Interview employees and supervisors: Ask questions about daily tasks, notable job changes, and the scope of responsibilities
- Compare results: Contrast job descriptions with new information to identify discrepancies and update descriptions
2. Review exemption and classification status
Once you have collected up-to-date job descriptions, you can review employee exemption and classification statuses. Assessing employee classifications can have major implications for your financial and organizational responsibilities.
For example, whether an employee is exempt or nonexempt influences timekeeping and overtime pay requirements. Salaried employees are also distinct from independent contractors, and these classifications impact tax structures, scheduling, and benefits administration.
3. Validate pay scales and testing logic
After the initial review of the data, you can assess and implement any necessary changes. As you proceed, it’s crucial to keep a critical eye on your methodology for making decisions. To avoid running into compliance issues, you may need to hire an outside expert or use automated payroll software.
To ensure that pay is consistent with internal and external standards, validate pay scales. Compare employee rates with industry standards to align competitive pay rates with market value, which should be reflective of employee skills and daily tasks.
4. Establish a regular audit cadence
Job audits are most effective when done on a routine schedule. The recommended frequency can depend on your industry, the number of employees, internal organizational factors, and macroeconomic conditions. Some SMBs conduct company-wide job audits on a quarterly, biannual, or annual basis. Others may complete more frequent audits for targeted subgroups. To ensure compliant and accurate payroll processes on an ongoing basis, establish a clear job audit cadence.
To help visualize the steps, we also break down this guidance in the table below.
| Step | What to do | Why it matters |
| Gather accurate job descriptions | Review existing job descriptions, interview employees, supervisors, and compare duties to find discrepancies. | Confirm each role reflects actual work performed and sets the stage for fair pay and proper classification. |
| Review exemption and classification status | Confirm whether each role is exempt or nonexempt, and identify independent contractors vs. employees. | Helps prevent misclassification errors that can lead to IRS penalties or wage claims. |
| Validate pay scales and decision logic | Compare internal pay rates with industry standards and assess consistency across similar roles. | Promotes pay equity and avoids disputes about overtime or pay fairness. |
| Establish a regular audit cadence | Decide on a schedule (quarterly, biannual, or annual) based on company size and industry. | Keeps your organization compliant and, as roles evolve, ensures pay practices stay current. |
Integrating job audits into your payroll strategy
Job audits shouldn’t be seen as a one-time fix, but part of your ongoing payroll and HR strategy. This integrated approach supports broader, longer-term risk management and compliance goals. You’ll continue to satisfy labor laws, avoid costly misclassification errors, and adhere to ethical pay structure principles. As well as protecting your business from legal exposure and financial loss, regular job audits also boost employee trust, satisfaction, and loyalty by prioritizing fairness and transparency.
Simple and affordable
“OnPay is very cost-effective and easy to use from any computer, anywhere. We can process payroll on an as-needed basis for different employee classifications, even from home.”
— Janet B., Smile Max Dental
Building these practices into your operations helps future-proof your organization. As SMBs grow, they need HR strategies and tools that can grow with them. Modern payroll software like OnPay integrates built-in reporting and job auditing tools that enable you to track job data in real time, flag inconsistencies, and generate compliant documentation. With the right tools, job audits can become a seamless part of your payroll process, positioning you for long-term success.
Bottom line: Job audits are an important part of running a business
Though they take time to conduct, job audits are a critical tool for SMBs. They help clarify job roles and worker classifications, maintain fair pay structures, overtime designations, and stay compliant with local, state, and federal labor laws. They also help build trust with your team.
With the right software, running job audits is easy. OnPay automates the process with advanced classification tools, customizable reporting, and built-in audit logs. The platform is designed to maximize accuracy and boost transparency, giving you a seamless, scalable user experience. Get started with OnPay and see the difference for yourself.
Take a tour to see how easy payroll can be.
Jon Davis is the Sr. Content Marketing Manager at OnPay. He has over 15 years of experience writing for small and growing businesses. Jon lives and works in Atlanta.